Teen Choice Awards: Comedian (2004)
Teen Choice Awards: Movie Actor - Comedy, 50 FIRST DATES (2004)
MTV Movie Awards: On-screen Team, 50 FIRST DATES (2004) - shared with Drew Barrymore
Kids' Choice Awards: Blimp Award - Favorite Movie Actor (2003)
Kids' Choice Awards: Blimp Award - Favorite Voice From an Animated Movie, EIGHT CRAZY NIGHTS (2003)
ShoWest Award: Male Star of the Year (2003)
Gijón International Film Festival: Best Actor, PUNCH-DRUNK LOVE (2002)
Teen Choice Awards: Choice Comedian (2002)
Teen Choice Awards: Choice Comedian (2001)
Blockbuster Entertainment Awards: Favorite Actor - Comedy, BIG DADDY (2000)
Kids' Choice Awards: Blimp Award - Favorite Movie Actor, BIG DADDY (2000)
MTV Movie Awards: Best Comedic Performance, BIG DADDY (2000)
People's Choice Awards: Favorite Motion Picture Star in a Comedy (2000)
Razzie Awards: Worst Actor, BIG DADDY (2000)
Blockbuster Entertainment Awards: Favorite Actor - Comedy, THE WATERBOY (1999)
MTV Movie Awards: Best Comedic Performance, THE WATERBOY (1999)
ShoWest Award: Special Award - Comedy Star of the Year (1999)
MTV Movie Awards: Best Kiss, THE WEDDING SINGER (1998) - shared with Drew Barrymore
MTV Movie Awards: Best Fight, HAPPY GILMORE (1996) - shared with Bob Barker